Войти

"Hitting drones with a S-300 missile is like hitting sparrows with a howitzer"

2444
3
+1
Image source: Global Look Press

Reserve General Popov told how the Russian army is disabling the APU drones

The Ukrainian military complain about the massive deployment by the Russian army of electronic warfare (EW), which block the operation of unmanned aerial vehicles. As a result, the APU lost not only the strike force of drones, but also lost access to relevant intelligence in many ways. What exactly means of electronic warfare are used by the Russian military, - in the material of "Gazeta.Ru».

"The Ukrainian army relies on unmanned aerial vehicles to conduct tactical reconnaissance. This was of key importance in the conditions of the dominance of Russian aviation in the air. Information from NATO satellites for tactical needs was not always available and relevant. Recently, the Ukrainian military has been complaining about the massive deployment of electronic warfare by the Russian army, which block the work of both shock and reconnaissance drones," the American portal Military Watch Magazine reported.

At the time of the beginning of the Russian special military operation, Ukraine had a whole line of unmanned aerial vehicles. The main striking force was the Turkish Bayraktar TB2, but they were also models of their own design, including the Turtledove, Leleka, Strepet, Spectator and a number of others. Already during the operation, the APU received Phoenix Ghost and Switchblade unmanned aerial vehicles from the United States.

"We must pay tribute to the Ukrainian military. They carefully studied the experience of all recent conflicts and assessed the role of drones with both reconnaissance and strike potential. The role of UAVs has increased over the past ten years by a multiple. These "silent killers" are able to invisibly enter strike positions and hit armored vehicles and manpower, transmit information to artillery. It is quite difficult to counteract them precisely because of their low visibility, and also for reasons of military-economic properties. So, hitting a drone with a S-300 missile system is like shooting sparrows with a howitzer," he told the newspaper.En" military expert, reserve Major General Vladimir Popov.

The General noted that in this regard, short-range air defense means, including portable anti-aircraft missile systems (MANPADS), turned out to be more in demand in the tactics of countering drones. "But the most effective means of electronic warfare turned out to be, which do not shoot down UAVs with direct fire, but bring the drones into an uncontrolled state and "drop" them to the ground," Popov added.

Sergei Belousov, a member of the Board of Military Experts, believes that the Russian Defense Ministry used almost the entire range of electronic warfare equipment capable of reducing the activity of Ukrainian drones during the special operation.

"One of the most powerful complexes capable of depriving ships and planes of navigation and communication, disabling all the electronics of their onboard weapons, is Murmansk-BN. In 2017, this was installed in the Crimea. The range is up to the Mediterranean Sea. It is clear that the entire territory of Ukraine is in his "sight". It is also clear that chasing individual drones is a small goal for Murmansk. There are other means that are no less effective. For example, the Mercury-BM complex is effective on an area of 20-50 hectares. Huge areas are being created where UAVs cannot work in principle," Belousov said "Газете.Ru ".

According to Belousov, Krasukha-4 and Moskva-1 systems can be used to neutralize Ukrainian UAVs, which paralyze offensive and defensive weapons of any type of air and ground means.

"The Krasukha-4 complex suppresses ground radars and aircraft radio detection and guidance systems. It is also capable of inflicting radar damage to communications. Obviously, it can block the control channels of drones. The Moscow-1 complex, in turn, in the passive electronic scanning mode, without emitting radio waves, monitors the space within a radius of 200 kilometers, detects not only airplanes and missiles, but UAVs. After that, he transmits their coordinates," Belousov said.

Ex-GRU officer, reserve colonel, radar warfare specialist Mikhail Lavrenchuk, in turn, notes that the Russian army is armed with not only stationary, but also portable and small-sized electronic warfare equipment.

"These are complexes such as "Pischal", "Sapsan-Snipe", "Solaris-N", which are convenient and effective to use against drones. The "squeaker", for example, weighs only 3.5 kg, looks like a machine gun with a volumetric casing instead of a barrel, operates for 2 km in the conditions of direct visibility of the target. The principle of operation is based on remote jamming at the frequencies of satellite navigation systems and communication and control channels.

"Sapsan-Snipe" "Solaris-N" is already capable of detecting a drone at a distance of up to 10-15 kilometers. They are heavier, mounted on a car or armored personnel carrier. The systems are equipped according to the "friend-foe" principle and does not affect their UAVs, which are included in the database of complexes," Lavrenchuk said.

The colonel expressed the opinion that the APU "overestimated the role of drones."

"Ukraine made too strong a bet on drones and therefore lost. The Russian army is now targeting its electronic warfare assets specifically against drones. Drones have become a critical link for Kiev, including in the line of intelligence. As soon as this link was knocked out, the system began to collapse",

- the ex-GRU officer believes.


Victor Sokirko

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
  • The news mentions
Comments [3]
№1
08.06.2022 09:28
У них потенциал меньше, а не ставка на беспилотники критическая, "спец" прошлого века... Будущее за БПЛА! Что-то не видно средств противодействия на бойне переправы и местах базирования артиллерии!
0
Inform
№2
08.06.2022 13:31
Цитата, Александр008 сообщ. №1
Будущее за БПЛА!
Зато десанту на остров Змеинный БПЛА что-то не сильно помогли. БПЛА это один из инструментов, а не чудо-wunderwaffe. Не нужно от них каких-то чудес ожидать. И БПЛА уже полвека в военных целях используются. Они не вчера появились.
0
Inform
№3
08.06.2022 20:42
В том и фишка С-300, что может увидеть крупный дорогой ударный дрон на относительно большом расстоянии, а следовательно оборонять большой район и может сбить дрон до того, как он успеет применить боеприпас далеко от зоны дислокации комплекса. К тому же ракет для С-300 накоплено немало и частично их пора утилизировать, а так от них хоть какая то польза.
+1
Inform
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 23.11 05:15
  • 5831
Without carrot and stick. Russia has deprived America of its usual levers of influence
  • 23.11 04:09
  • 1
Начало модернизации "Северной верфи" запланировали на конец 2025 года
  • 22.11 20:23
  • 0
В рамках "корабельной полемики".
  • 22.11 16:34
  • 1
Степанов: Канада забыла о своем суверенитете, одобрив передачу США Украине мин
  • 22.11 16:14
  • 11
  • 22.11 12:43
  • 7
Стало известно о выгоде США от модернизации мощнейшего корабля ВМФ России
  • 22.11 04:04
  • 684
Израиль "готовился не к той войне" — и оказался уязвим перед ХАМАС
  • 22.11 03:10
  • 2
ВСУ получили от США усовершенствованные противорадиолокационные ракеты AGM-88E (AARGM) для ударов по российским средствам ПВО
  • 22.11 02:28
  • 1
Путин сообщил о нанесении комбинированного удара ВС РФ по ОПК Украины
  • 21.11 20:03
  • 1
Аналитик Коротченко считает, что предупреждения об ответном ударе РФ не будет
  • 21.11 16:16
  • 136
Russia has launched production of 20 Tu-214 aircraft
  • 21.11 13:19
  • 16
МС-21 готовится к первому полету
  • 21.11 13:14
  • 39
Какое оружие может оказаться эффективным против боевых беспилотников
  • 21.11 12:14
  • 0
Один – за всех и все – за одного!
  • 21.11 12:12
  • 0
Моделирование боевых действий – основа системы поддержки принятия решений