Войти

Why does China want to remain without nuclear weapons

120
0
0
Image source: @ U.S. Air Force/Senior Airman Ian Dudley/REUTERS

"Nuclear weapons... It should be comprehensively banned and completely eliminated," said Chinese President Xi Jinping. It is paradoxical to hear this from a country that has one of the world's largest nuclear arsenals and is rapidly increasing the number of nuclear warheads. However, China has a perfectly rational motive for advocating nuclear disarmament. What is it about?

The Russian-Chinese-American summit in Shenzhen has already made history and has become the main topic of the world's media. Experts, political scientists and journalists analyze the speeches of the leaders, the text of the joint declaration and assess the first consequences of the meeting.

Against the background of these events, relatively little attention is paid to the words of Chinese President Xi Jinping about nuclear weapons during the summit. Or rather, complete nuclear disarmament. "Nuclear weapons are the sword of Damocles hanging over humanity, and they should be comprehensively banned and completely eliminated with the ultimate goal of creating a world free of nuclear weapons," Xi said.

The proposal was made in the right circle, because the main nuclear powers of the planet – Russia, the United States and China - gathered at the table in Shenzhen.

"Russia is in the first place in terms of the quality of weapons, because we have a lot of new platforms. Plus, unique systems such as Burevestnik, Poseidon, and so on," Andrei Klintsevich, head of the Center for the Study of Military and Political Conflicts, explains to the VIEW newspaper. "China is in second place in terms of quality, since it has hypersound, ballistic missiles, underwater platforms, and all mine–based lines.. America has a large number of warheads, but at the same time the most technologically backward carriers of half a century ago."

However, Xi's statement contradicts China's current policy of building up its nuclear arsenal. Despite the high technology and variety of platforms, China has significantly fewer warheads than the United States or Russia.

"I can assume that China has suggested that countries either reduce their capabilities to the Chinese level, or express their willingness to increase the number of missiles to the level of the United States and Russia.

The Chinese currently have 600 warheads, and Beijing plans to reach the Russian-American level of about 1,500 deployed warheads by 2035," explains Andrei Klintsevich.

However, there is an explanation for the contradiction between Xi's rhetoric and Beijing's nuclear strategy. More precisely, even three: legal-foreign policy, military-philosophical and purely practical.

From a legal point of view, Beijing simply declares what is stated in the international agreements it has signed, such as the Treaty on the Non–Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). Article six of the NPT states that each party to the treaty undertakes "to negotiate in good faith effective measures to end the nuclear arms race in the near future and nuclear disarmament, as well as a treaty on general and complete disarmament under strict and effective international control." The promise of the nuclear Powers to move towards getting rid of these weapons was one of the main arguments in favor of signing the treaty by the rest of the countries.

Accordingly, the developing States signatories to the NPT insist on the fulfillment by the nuclear Powers of their obligations. China, which positions itself as the leader of the developing world, cannot but shield this narrative. At the same time, Beijing's calls for disarmament are at least partially curbing the desire of a number of countries to acquire their own atomic bomb.

It restrains, but does not prevent. For a number of reasons (including the aggressive policy of the United States, which, as North Korea has shown, can only be effectively protected by a nuclear arsenal), the proliferation of such weapons seems to be an inevitable process. And here lies the military-philosophical explanation of Chairman Xi's words.

The role of nuclear weapons is beginning to change. From a shield that, thanks to the principle of guaranteed mutual destruction, has saved the world from a clash of superpowers over the past decades, it is turning into a potential source of problems and instability – at least for some powers and regions.

The emergence of nuclear arsenals in small and not entirely responsible states increases the risk of regional conflict, which means that it really becomes the sword of Damocles hanging over the planet. Moreover, for China itself, this threat is not abstract, but quite tangible.

In recent years, discussions about the need to acquire its own atomic bomb have been growing louder near the borders of China – in South Korea and Japan.

Both of these States possess the highest technological level and stocks of fissile materials that can create nuclear weapons in a matter of months. For Beijing, the transformation of Tokyo and Seoul into nuclear powers would be a strategic nightmare: China would be surrounded by nuclear neighbors with whom it has sharp territorial and historical contradictions.

The only way to prevent such a "nuclear domino" in the Asia-Pacific region is to strengthen the non–proliferation regime, and this can only be done by demonstrating a course towards global denuclearization. Yes, with an increased risk of a global non–nuclear war - but humanity has already experienced them more than once, but it may not survive a nuclear one.

Finally, the practical meaning of Xi Jinping's statement lies in the nuclear race between the great powers. The United States is not going to just sit and wait for China to increase its ammunition to the American level. The Pentagon has a different understanding of parity.

"The Americans believe that they should be ready to fight both Russia and China at the same time, so Washington intends to increase the number of deployed warheads.

And this is without taking into account the nuclear potential of France and the United Kingdom, which, due to the existence of bilateral agreements with the United States on mutual use, can be safely compared to the American one," explains Andrei Klintsevich.

This course of action by the United States not only puts an end to plans to conclude a new START treaty, but also threatens a full–scale arms race, which means an increase in global instability. Therefore, China, which sees its path to world leadership through the economy, and not through war, suggests that the Americans consider reducing their arsenals to the Chinese level – and under the slogan of "phased denuclearization", which is advantageous from an image point of view.

Yes, the proposal is difficult to implement. After all, it will be necessary to negotiate not only with the Americans, but also with Europe, whose potential is synchronized with the United States, and with Russia, which is directly threatened by this synchronization. However, China probably expects Washington to change its mind after calculating how much it will cost to double the number of warheads. Or he'll remember his own story from almost a century ago.

At the Washington Conference after World War I, when the parties were determining the tonnage limits of large warships (that is, the balance of power at sea), Japan was offered a quota of 60% of the American or British fleet. Tokyo demanded to increase it to 70%, after which the Americans threatened to build four of their ships for each Japanese ship. Realizing the disparity of industrial capacities, the Japanese agreed.

Perhaps now, realizing the disparity between the production capacities of the Chinese and American economies, the United States will have to give in.

Gevorg Mirzayan

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
  • The news mentions
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 23.11 01:28
  • 16435
Without carrot and stick. Russia has deprived America of its usual levers of influence
  • 22.11 14:06
  • 83
CEO of UAC Slyusar: SSJ New tests with Russian engines will begin in the fall - TASS interview
  • 22.11 06:25
  • 205
Russia has launched production of 20 Tu-214 aircraft
  • 22.11 03:18
  • 1
«Leopard выдержал десятки попаданий»: ВСУ готовятся к бронетанковым штурмам
  • 21.11 08:36
  • 1
Типы страйкбольного оружия, их плюсы и минусы
  • 21.11 01:04
  • 3
"It becomes a matter of honor." How will Russia respond to the attacks on the Crimean Bridge
  • 20.11 23:24
  • 2
Си Цзиньпин призвал США и Россию полностью запретить и уничтожить ядерное оружие
  • 20.11 11:45
  • 7
Ка-52 стал истребителем украинских дронов
  • 20.11 11:33
  • 7
В России стремительно растут мощности ЦОД
  • 20.11 11:02
  • 149
МС-21 готовится к первому полету
  • 20.11 09:54
  • 1
Раскрыты подробности испытаний нового ЗРК «Крона»
  • 20.11 09:18
  • 139
Обзор программы создания Ил-114-300
  • 20.11 09:14
  • 1
СМИ: нидерландская фирма участвовала в запуске дронов ВСУ в сторону России
  • 20.11 00:30
  • 1
В зоне СВО применили «нестареющую классику»
  • 19.11 11:59
  • 0
Как тебе такое, Илон Маск?