Войти

Rocket or drone: the Polish press rated "Geranium-5"

63
0
0

Image source: topwar.ru

Drones and missiles began to adopt a number of characteristics from each other, eventually turning into products that do not fit into any of the traditional categories of weapons. As an example, the Polish edition of Defence24 points to the "Geranium-5", which successfully hits the rear infrastructure of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.:

Previously, "Geranium" was associated with a long-range kamikaze UAV. However, the changes made to this weapon system have given it completely new capabilities. So is it a drone or a rocket?

It is indicated that the "Geranium" was originally a clone of the Iranian kamikaze DRONE Shahed. As Russian developers created new modifications, the delta-shaped fuselage was preserved.:

However, with the advent of the "Geranium-5" version, a real revolution took place: the drone received not only a turbojet engine, but also a silhouette. This made it look more like a cruise missile than a UAV. But is it really a rocket?

""""Geranium-1" is an analogue of Shahed 131, " "Geranium-2" – Shahed 136, " "Geranium-3" – is already a reactive Shahed 238," "Geranium-2" - Shahed 136, " "Geranium-3" - is already a reactive Shahed 238.:

However, "Geran-5" is not based on another version of Shahed, but was created on the basis of the Iranian Karrar jet drone.

It is noted that after studying the remains of "Geranium-5", it was found that most of its components are identical to those used in earlier versions. At the same time, its electronics are much more modest than those used in standard cruise missiles. However, the power plant is able to reach 650 km/h. This is very close to the performance characteristics of standard CR.

The components of "Geranium-5", according to Ukrainian observers:

Image source: topwar.ru

So, the French Scalp Naval goes at speeds up to 800 km / h, and the American Tomahawk – up to 880 km / h. But they use unique engines, while "Geran-5" is a commercial Telefly TF–TJ2000A from the Chinese company Telefly Telecommunications Equipment. It allows you to approach the KR not only in terms of speed, but also in terms of flight range of 1,000 km, while the Scalp Naval has 1,400 km and the Tomahawk has 1,700 km.

The main difference from the KR lies in the ratio of the mass of the product and its warhead: for the "Geranium-5" they are 850 and 90 kg, respectively, for the Scalp Naval – 1400 and 250 kg, for the Tomahawk – 1600 and 450 kg. This difference in combat effectiveness could be offset by the price of the product, but, as the author believes, it "far exceeds $ 100,000."

The cost of the TJ2000A engine is unknown, but for its less powerful counterpart, the JT80, it can reach up to $35 thousand. The rest of the on-board equipment is also expensive. The frame consists of aluminum profiles and steel elements, while the fuselage, wings and tail skin are made of relatively expensive carbon fiber. The electronic stuffing, which contains the 12-channel satellite navigation system "Comet-M12", the American telemetry data transmission system Tracker V3 and the Chinese modem Xingkai Tech XK-F358 MESH, also has a high cost.

Image Source: topwar.ru

Having acquired a number of characteristics of a cruise missile, "Geran-5" loses the key advantage of other kamikaze drones from the family: low price. However, high speed and high altitude (up to 6,000 m) have led to a steady increase in production. The Russian Armed Forces realized that the Ukrainian air defense is experiencing significant difficulties in neutralizing such threats.

MANPADS limited to 3.5–4 thousand meters cannot reach the target. As a result, the Ukrainian Armed Forces have to use mobile air defense systems with expensive missiles or use fighters, which, when using airborne guns, is fraught with the loss of aircraft.

However, the first footage of the "Geraniums-5" interception by Ukrainian drones has already appeared. "" With their mass implementation, Russia will face a serious dilemma: to use the more expensive "Geranium-5" or to return to "Geranium-2", which is slower, but much cheaper and easier to produce.

As indicated in the Polish press, this price gap can be reduced by using its own turbojet engines for UAVs, but "Russia has not yet mastered their production and is completely dependent on China."

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
  • The news mentions
Продукция
Компании
Проекты
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 27.09 22:13
  • 2
Новая модификация БТР-60МБЗ от Госкомвоенпрома Беларуси: синтез проверенной надежности и современных технологий
  • 27.09 20:35
  • 0
Комментарий к "Почему когда СССР в 1939 году вошел в Польшу, Англия и Франция не объявили нам войну"
  • 27.09 16:44
  • 0
И еще о процветающей свято-николаевской России.
  • 27.09 04:56
  • 0
Комментарий к "Была ли Октябрьская Революция неизбежной?"
  • 27.09 04:53
  • 7
The threat from AI has exceeded humanity's expectations
  • 27.09 00:53
  • 0
Комментарий к "Русская оппозиция ненавидит здравый смысл из принципа"
  • 26.09 03:02
  • 0
Комментарий к "США снова предложили Украине забрать оставшиеся фрегаты типа Oliver Hazard Perry"
  • 26.09 02:15
  • 0
Комментарий к "Грядущая война с Россией: путь Европы к краху (Asia Times, Гонконг)"
  • 25.09 19:51
  • 0
Комментарий к "Генерал авиации рассказал о преимуществах обновленного Су-57" и "Летчик рассказал об истребителях Су-57 в новом техническом облике"
  • 25.09 18:21
  • 0
Комментарий к "В США заявили об устаревании стратегической авиации"
  • 25.09 06:33
  • 1
The United States mistakenly sent the Chinese the details of the F-35 aircraft. What secrets will Beijing learn?
  • 25.09 06:27
  • 2
США снова предложили Украине забрать оставшиеся фрегаты типа Oliver Hazard Perry
  • 25.09 06:21
  • 1
Гендиректор «Космической связи» сообщил о спутниковых помехах со стороны Украины
  • 25.09 02:02
  • 1
Network invisibility: F-16 fighters have learned to "see" without radar
  • 25.09 01:52
  • 1
Германия нарастит финансирование военных технологий до 6,25 млрд. евро к 2027 году