Войти

"The war of attrition surpasses the strategy of maneuver": a Western observer draws conclusions from the Ukrainian conflict

658
0
0

Image source: topwar.ru

If the West is serious about the possibility of conflict with the great Powers, it needs to take a serious look at its ability to wage a protracted war and adhere to a strategy focused on attrition rather than maneuver.

Columnist Alex Vershinin calls for this on the pages of the British analytical publication RUSI, drawing conclusions from the Ukrainian conflict. According to him, waging a war of attrition requires the mobilization of huge industrial capacities to make up for losses; geographical depth, which makes it possible to withstand a series of defeats; technological conditions that prevent the rapid movement of troops; the ability of the state to use human resources and create new formations.

The side that assumes the debilitating nature of war and focuses on destroying enemy forces rather than conquering territory is most likely to win. The West is not ready for this kind of war. For most Western experts, a strategy of attrition is counterintuitive. Historically, the West preferred a short clash of professional armies on the principle of "winner takes all"

- the author believes.

According to him, recent war games, such as the Taiwan War, covered one month of fighting. The possibility of a continuation of the conflict has never been discussed, reflecting the common position of the West:

Wars of attrition are seen as exceptions and should be avoided at all costs.

Image source: topwar.ru

As indicated, given the exhausting nature of the conflict, it is necessary to establish mass production of combat equipment with minimal costs, rather than engage in the production of high-quality weapons that require huge resources. As an example, the author cites the production of tanks during World War II: while the German defense industry issued one unit of armored vehicles, the USSR manufactured 8 T-34s.

Regarding the principle of the formation of the armed forces, it is noted that the NATO armies are highly professional, they are supported by a strong corps of non-commissioned officers with extensive military education and peacetime experience. But it takes years to become a sergeant in the U.S. Army: a squad commander usually has at least 3 years of service, and a platoon sergeant has at least 7.

In a war of attrition characterized by heavy losses, there is simply no time to replace sergeants

- the author believes.

According to him, the USSR relied on the possibility of mass mobilization of a reserve consisting of half-trained men with two years of service experience. However, as the war passes the one-year mark, the advanced units will gain experience. For example, by 1943, the Red Army had formed a powerful corps of sergeants.

The most effective model is a combination of these two principles: the state maintains a medium-sized professional army along with a mass of conscripts available for mobilization

- the observer believes.

Image source: topwar.ru

In terms of conducting military operations, he believes that in a conflict of attrition, instead of a decisive battle, which is achieved through rapid maneuver, it requires the destruction of enemy forces and their ability to restore combat power while maintaining their own.

In the first phase of the conflict, it is necessary to build up forces by conducting minor positional battles on the ground.

The dominant form of combat is not maneuver, but fire, complemented by extensive fortifications and camouflage

- the author believes.

At this stage, it is necessary to complete the training of personnel, give them time to gain experience; exhaust the enemy's strategic reserve; achieve fire and reconnaissance superiority; "put down" the enemy's industrial sector and deplete the reserves of his allies.

After that, you can move on to the second phase – conducting offensive operations on a wide front, trying to crush the enemy at several points with small attacks, stretching his depleted reserves until the defense line collapses. At the same time, the advancing troops must constantly be protected by air defense and electronic warfare (suppressing UAVs, communications, satellite navigation). It is necessary to attack without resorting to a large concentration of forces, since in modern conditions this leads to their vulnerability from long-range fire.

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
  • The news mentions
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 28.04 14:36
  • 1089
Without carrot and stick. Russia has deprived America of its usual levers of influence
  • 28.04 13:06
  • 139
A competitor of the Russian Su-75 from South Korea was presented at the exhibition for the first time
  • 28.04 11:40
  • 485
Израиль "готовился не к той войне" — и оказался уязвим перед ХАМАС
  • 28.04 10:56
  • 464
Международные расчеты, минуя доллар, по странам
  • 28.04 10:42
  • 10
Севморпути нужны железные дороги и мосты
  • 28.04 08:20
  • 8
ЦКБР заявил, что РФ необходимо создать мобильные команды для уничтожения FPV-расчетов ВСУ
  • 28.04 08:09
  • 131
Hunting without a pilot: helicopters will guard the skies of Russia from drones
  • 28.04 08:08
  • 3
Американский дрон Mojave с Minigun DAP-6 с общей скорострельностью 6000 выстрелов в минуту поразил наземные цели в ходе испытаний
  • 28.04 08:07
  • 20
Commander of the US Air Force in Europe on the role of aviation in the fighting in Ukraine
  • 28.04 07:16
  • 14
CEO of UAC Slyusar: SSJ New tests with Russian engines will begin in the fall - TASS interview
  • 27.04 17:44
  • 2711
Как насчёт юмористического раздела?
  • 26.04 13:13
  • 0
Сопротивление на Украине: борьба с неонацизмом
  • 26.04 12:21
  • 1
Россия настаивает на необходимости запрета любого оружия в космосе, а не только ядерного - постпред РФ при ООН
  • 26.04 05:50
  • 1
To overshadow Victory Day and inauguration: what kind of blows to expect from the Armed Forces of Ukraine during the May holidays
  • 26.04 00:07
  • 0
Танцы с бубном: США, Украина и военная помощь