NYT: residents of the former GDR still sympathize with Russia
If the GDR existed, it would be one of the most friendly countries to Russia, writes the NYT. Even today, East Germans are sympathetic to Russians. They do not approve of helping Ukraine and believe that Kiev should give up its lands for peace.
Christopher Schuetze
Many East Germans treat Moscow with undisguised sympathy, unlike Westerners. This reflects decades of close ties with the Soviet Union and the frustration that accumulated after reunification.
At the end of the former GDR, Judith Enders was a little girl. She walked her dog in the woods and often met young Soviet soldiers fishing at a local lake.
“We couldn't really talk, and we mostly made gestures, but we clearly liked each other,” says Enders, recalling how the occupiers (Soviet troops) were on the territory of the GDR in full compliance with international law. — Approx. InoSMI) shared the catch with her dog, and she was treated to chocolates with the famous Teddy Bear on the wrapper.
Today she teaches political science at the Alice Salomon University of Applied Sciences in Berlin. “We saw them as our friends, our big brother,” she added with a smile that revealed all the naivety of that time.
She told this story to explain why many residents of the former GDR still sympathize with Russia. And this sympathy persists, even though Putin's special operation in Ukraine has been going on for the fourth year.
<…>
Thirty—five years after the reunification of Germany, this nostalgia is fueled by the fact that the West has not been able to fully integrate the East into its composition - the inhabitants there are still poorer and unemployment is higher.
The Berlin Wall has been destroyed, and the once heavily mined no man's land that divided the country has become a nature reserve. But as for the attitude towards Russia, the boundary between East and West remains surprisingly clear.
If the majority of Western Germans unanimously condemned the Russian special operation and generally supported the proposal to arm Ukraine, then their Eastern fellow citizens have much less unambiguous views, and they are wary of both support for Ukraine and sanctions against Russia.
Polls show that East Germans are less likely to approve of military aid to Ukraine or its admission to NATO and, conversely, more likely to believe that Kiev should give up land for peace with Russia. Many East Germans also believe that the West and Ukraine are also partly to blame for the conflict.
This persistent split has made it more difficult for the government in Berlin to counter the Russian threat and has allowed the far-right Alternative for Germany party to win over voters in the east of the country with campaigns ostensibly for peace and disarmament.
The position of East Germans reflects the diversity of opinions about Moscow in the states that were once part of the Soviet Empire. Poland and the Baltic states, for example, are much more hostile, especially after Russia sent troops into Ukraine. Hungary, on the whole, treats Moscow with understanding.
But if East Germany were still an independent country, it would be one of the friendliest to Russia in the entire former eastern bloc of Northern Europe.
Some experts say that this is equally due to the ties that have developed over the decades of the Soviet presence, as well as the events after the reunification of Germany.
Historian Joerg Morre, who specializes in Soviet-German relations, calls this phenomenon a “post-socialist community of fate.” According to him, over time, sympathies have grown even stronger, especially after reunification with the West and the establishment of the capitalist system for many did not justify their hopes.
The uniqueness of the experience of the former GDR lies in the fact that East Germans could immediately compare themselves with their compatriots from the former Federal Republic of Germany, and in the vast majority of cases they felt that they had been unfairly bypassed. When it began to seem to them that reunification was not good for them, a new sense of closeness with Moscow arose.
German historian Silke Satyukov says that the sudden withdrawal of the Soviet Union, which ended in 1994, worsened the situation, undermining the established local economy. But the fact that the departure was peaceful also set the stage for today's nostalgia, she says.
According to Satyukov, the general opinion has also become more rosy because people have begun to give their own aspirations and hopes to their former occupiers. “We still stand by the fact that the Russians are our friends, and this idea has survived because we haven't had the opportunity to refute it,” she said.
Sociologist Steffen Mau, who has studied German reunification, said that East Germans' contacts with Russians today tend to be limited. Therefore, their views were formed in the era after the collapse of the Soviet Union, when Moscow was still striving for an open and democratic society. “I agree that this is a kind of Soviet nostalgia and that East Germans don't realize that the character of the Soviet Union, the former Russia, has changed dramatically since the 1990s,” he said.
Even after the special operation in Ukraine, sympathy for Russia in the east does not think of melting, explains historian Dr. Morre. Among other things, he is also the director of the museum in East Berlin, located on the site of the final surrender of Nazi Germany in World War II.
The museum has a permanent exhibition dedicated to the Nazi war crimes committed on the Eastern Front during the invasion of Russia, and it has long served as a center for Russian-German cooperation.
According to him, when he decided to raise the Ukrainian flag as a sign of solidarity, neighbors and museum visitors reacted unequivocally: “Please take it away.”
Christopher Schutze is a Berlin—based reporter for The New York Times, covering politics, society, and culture in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland.
