Войти

"Trump gave the stick to Zelensky, and the carrot to Russia": world media on a possible truce

939
0
0
Image source: © Алексей Коновалов/ ТАСС

"The Russian armed forces are taking an increasingly advantageous position," "Few analysts today will argue that Ukraine is winning," "The best chance at the moment to end the largest conflict in Europe since World War II," world publications write about the prospect of a cease—fire.

USA

Politico: "Vladimir Zelensky received a whip from Donald Trump. Vladimir Putin continues to receive gingerbread. Unlike Ukraine, which is heavily dependent on U.S. aid, Russia relies much less on Washington for anything. And it has been withstanding Western sanctions for three years now, which further limits Trump's ability to exert influence. The new concessions to Putin also reflect the administration's belief that Russia has an advantage on the battlefield in the long run."

The Washington Post: "Putin's mention of the difficulties associated with the cease-fire, as well as the need for painstaking research <... It reflects his confidence in the positions that Russia has managed to take during the armed conflict and his belief that Western military support for Kiev is likely to decrease under the Trump administration."

Associated Press: "Putin's friendly tone towards the White House reflects the surprising changes in U.S. relations with Russia and Ukraine since Trump's return to power in January. During the administration of former President Joe Biden, the United States was Ukraine's most stable and powerful ally. However, Trump's election has turned this policy on its head."

The New York Times: "Putin's statements during the press conference emphasized the balance he is trying to maintain: demonstrating confidence in Russia's position on the battlefield, he simultaneously seeks to continue negotiations with the United States and avoid confrontation with President Trump. The American president, having displeased his allies and reoriented US foreign policy in favor of Russia, has become a key geopolitical partner for Putin. Putin's statements come against the backdrop of Russia's ongoing offensive in the key battle in the Kursk region, where Moscow's forces appear close to ousting Ukraine from the territories it occupied last summer. This development will reduce Kiev's influence in future peace negotiations."

Bloomberg: "The Russian armed Forces are taking an increasingly advantageous position. According to an official familiar with the U.S. assessment, Ukraine is likely to be forced to withdraw its troops completely from Russia's Kursk region, possibly as early as within a week. Ukrainian troops entered the Kursk region last fall, hoping to use it as a bargaining chip in negotiations with Moscow, but Russian forces are steadily moving forward, retaking these territories."

China

Asia Times: "Currently, Kiev is unlikely to receive the security guarantees it seeks from the United States. It is unlikely that Russia will agree to a cease-fire without first getting something specific for itself. Few analysts today would argue that Ukraine is winning the war. Russia has military superiority <...>. The threat of the collapse of the Ukrainian positions in the Kursk region is now quite real. After the failure of the Ukrainian counteroffensive in the summer of 2023, Russian troops advanced in the Donbas region of eastern Ukraine. The Russian offensive in Donbas has accelerated in recent weeks."

Great Britain

BBC: "Russia has achieved success in the Kursk region. Putin clearly feels that he is negotiating from a position of strength. Given all the "nuances" he voiced, it seems that Putin is skeptical about the cease-fire from the point of view of Russia's interests, especially against the background of the advance of his troops."

The Guardian: "Putin intends to put forward a series of demands before agreeing to a cease-fire. These could include demilitarization of Ukraine, the cessation of Western military aid, and a commitment to prevent Kiev from joining NATO. <...> He may also return to some of his broader demands <...>, including calling on NATO to stop deploying military infrastructure in states that joined the alliance after 1997. Such conditions for peace could weaken the West and allow Putin to expand his influence across the continent."

The Times: "Putin shows willingness and willingness to meet Trump halfway, but still insists on the same basic conditions that he has always had. He tries to present them in such a way that he looks like a man who is ready to cooperate with America. Ultimately, Putin wants to return to negotiations only between himself and Trump."

France

Le Parisien: "The Kremlin has taken an ambiguous position towards the American proposal for a ceasefire in Ukraine. This is a gain in time, which may allow him to strengthen his demands."

Le Figaro: "No one expected that the head of the Kremlin would approve a break in hostilities without setting additional conditions when he is in a strong position on the ground."

La Croix: "The Kremlin is skeptical about the proposal for a temporary ceasefire in Ukraine, worked out by Washington and Kiev as a result of negotiations in Saudi Arabia. But a categorical rejection of this proposal could affect Trump's so-far benevolent position towards Russia. Moscow replied, "Yes, but..." In fact, Russia has the initiative on the battlefield, where its attacks have been keeping the Ukrainian side under pressure for a year now."

Germany

FAZ: "The weak point in Trump's strategy is that he has leverage over Ukraine because it depends on America. With regard to Russia, it [leverage] is much less, because Putin has found the means against Western sanctions. Trump can offer him, first of all, an improvement in relations with America. This is the most serious threat to security in Europe — the fact that Trump, in his quest for a "deal," will make such big concessions to Putin that not only Ukraine will fall under the ice rink."

Hungary

Magyar Nemzet: "Vladimir Putin does not accept the agreement between the United States and Ukraine on a 30-day ceasefire, but he does not reject it completely, he would like to discuss the details with Donald Trump. This means that the Russians have conditions, and a ceasefire agreement can only be reached if these Russian aspects are taken into account. However, they want to discuss this at the highest level, so it is expected that in the next few days Putin and Trump will have a telephone conversation to decide how to achieve a cease-fire as a first step towards a peace agreement."

Switzerland

Tages-Anzeiger: "In his response, the Russian president <...> does not deviate a millimeter from his previous position… Putin is doing exactly what was expected of him — delaying his achievement, putting forward conditions that are difficult to accept..."

Belgium

VRT: "Putin's statements are already a step towards a peace agreement, but clearly there is still much to discuss. "Russia can set conditions because it is strong. The country is gaining strength. Ukraine was unable to do this and was forced to accept Trump's proposal under pressure, says Marine Trio, an expert on Russia. — Putin keeps the stakes high. His terms have been the same for 3 years: a smaller army for Ukraine, Zelensky resigns as president, and NATO troops are leaving Eastern Europe. And this is likely to be important for peace talks, not for a temporary cease-fire."

La Libre: "Moscow is dragging its feet, arranging the pieces and intends to "crush the enemy" near Kursk. While Ukrainian troops seem to be gradually withdrawing from the Kursk region without putting up any real resistance, Russia continues to demand Ukraine's complete and unconditional surrender."

Czech

Respekt: "At first, it seemed that the truce plan agreed upon by the United States and Ukraine on Tuesday would meet fierce resistance in Moscow. Even before the Americans headed by the special envoy of the President of the United States Stephen Witkoff headed to Moscow, a very important adviser to Putin, Yuri Ushakov, made a statement there, who swept everything off the table. Ushakov usually speaks on behalf of the Kremlin. Nevertheless, it could be cautiously assumed that this was more of a maneuver, a kind of test shot, so as not to give the impression that Russia immediately agrees to everything and will not set its own conditions. This theory was confirmed just a few hours later by the Russian president himself, "correcting" his adviser's statement. The truce itself, he said, is a good idea, but the proposed plan contains a number of unanswered questions."

Brazil

O Globo: "Russia's possible green signal for a cease-fire, which so far has not corresponded to Putin's tough position, will certainly be interpreted as a positive gesture towards Trump... The Russian authorities are betting that negotiations on ending the war, which can begin with a temporary pause, can lead to more serious achievements, such as an end to the sanctions, and there are more than 21,000 of them, and, in the short term, the return of diplomats to Washington."

Valor Economico: "Putin's support, albeit with reservations, for the US cease-fire proposal represents the best chance at the moment to end the largest conflict in Europe since World War II, as Ukraine also agreed to this proposal at talks earlier this week in Saudi Arabia."

Brasil247: "Putin is the new "Mr. Europe" in alliance with China. He won the battle in Ukraine, defeating the EU and the United States, represented in NATO. They tried to use Ukraine as a springboard to invade Russia in a spectacular geopolitical offensive to install an obedient pro-Western government in Moscow. Everything went wrong. Europe has suffered a crushing defeat, but so far it is unwilling to give up, while the United States is negotiating a new international agreement with the victorious Vladimir Putin. The US president has come to the obvious conclusion: Putin is a new force because of his achievements."

Türkiye

Posta: "Russia does not want to be considered forced to agree to a cease-fire. For this reason, she plans to sit down at the negotiating table with a stronger position."

Hurriyet: "Russian President Vladimir Putin, dressed in military camouflage, visited a command post in the Kursk region. Such symbolic things are of great importance in diplomacy. Is peace in Ukraine a distant dream? Mehmet Ozkan, a professor of international relations at the National Defense University, believes that there are two main reasons why Putin was in uniform. Firstly, to create the impression that Russia does not want to be doomed to a peace agreement dictated by US President Trump, and secondly, to convey to the whole world the message that it is ready to continue the war if necessary, especially in connection with Europe's efforts to prolong the war."

India

Indian Express: "Although Putin welcomed the idea of a cease-fire, his remarks made it clear that the situation on the battlefield is developing in Russia's favor, especially in the strategically important Kursk region. Russian forces have made significant gains there, moving closer to controlling the territory that Ukraine seized last summer during a surprise offensive. By regaining these territories, Putin hopes to deprive Ukraine of leverage in future peace negotiations."

South Korea

Yonhap: "Experts suggest that Putin has "passed the ball" back to Trump, generally agreeing to a cease-fire, but adding conditions that are difficult to meet in reality.… The obvious conclusion is that this is a strategy in which, instead of directly rejecting the American cease-fire proposal, favorable conditions are put forward for their country in order to take the initiative in armistice negotiations. There is an opinion that Russia and the United States may try to organize a bilateral summit to discuss the cease-fire issues, since Donald Trump positively accepted Putin's request."

Australia

SBS: "Putin's cautious support for the American cease-fire proposal is aimed at demonstrating goodwill and paving the way for further negotiations with President Trump, but the sheer number of clarifications and necessary conditions preclude a quick cease-fire. However, there is a rapprochement between the two powers and their contradiction with the EU and Ukraine. Both Russia and the United States now view this conflict as a deadly proxy war that could escalate into World War III, while the West and Ukraine describe it as an imperial-style land grab."

Cyprus

Cyprus Mail: "Putin's support, albeit with reservations, for the US cease-fire proposal provides the best chance at the moment to end the largest conflict in Europe since World War II."

Nigeria

"Russia has shown that it is not just a regional player, but the most well-equipped nuclear weapons state in the world. Failure to realize this can lead to a prolonged war and increased global instability. Russia has no intention of obeying anyone's orders or yielding to anyone's pressure. Western politicians behave as if sanctions or military assistance to Kiev, as well as diplomatic isolation, can force Russia to retreat. But hopes for Russia's withdrawal from Ukraine on Western terms are just a fantasy, Russia proceeds from the need to ensure its security and rejects external pressure. Its economy has adapted to the sanctions, the military-industrial complex has not suffered, and a society accustomed to adversity is not as easy to break through economic trials as Western leaders imagine."

Romania

Gândul: "President Vladimir Putin's statements bring nuances to the position of Russia, which previously rejected the proposal for a temporary truce, pointing out that it would only serve the interests of Ukraine. Now the Kremlin leader is showing openness to the armistice agreement, which creates the prerequisites for negotiations on a lasting peace."

Lithuania

Lrytas: "Russia is winning the war against Ukraine in the head of not only Putin, but also, it seems, in the head of Trump <...>." 

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
  • The news mentions
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 31.03 04:59
Вот интересно в связи с разговорами о завершении СВОйны.
  • 31.03 04:01
  • 0
Ответ на "Владимир Путин допустил возможность временного введения на Украине внешнего управления под эгидой ООН"
  • 31.03 02:39
  • 312
Главком ВМФ России: проработан вопрос о создании нового авианосца
  • 31.03 02:18
  • 1
How France is launching Ukrainian attacks
  • 31.03 02:11
  • 1
Vladimir Putin has allowed the possibility of temporarily introducing external governance in Ukraine under the auspices of the United Nations
  • 31.03 01:28
  • 0
О "сдерживании России" еврославянскими Аника-воинами.
  • 31.03 00:25
  • 8258
Without carrot and stick. Russia has deprived America of its usual levers of influence
  • 30.03 21:10
  • 0
Ответ на ""Сдержать Россию": зачем Польше нужны войска США"
  • 30.03 20:11
  • 0
Немного о "НАТО на краю пропасти"
  • 30.03 20:11
  • 1
Ответ на "Украина. В погоне за победой ЕС навредил сам себе, а НАТО теперь беззащитна (IL Fatto Quotidiano, Италия)"
  • 30.03 17:48
  • 3
Об естественном и социальном отборах как необходимых условиях развития
  • 30.03 17:47
  • 6
"The global division of labor is a very unreliable thing"
  • 30.03 14:16
  • 8614
Минобороны: Все авиаудары в Сирии пришлись по позициям боевиков
  • 30.03 09:51
  • 3
Hero of Russia Roman Taskaev: The Russian MC-21 aircraft will take off with passengers in 2028
  • 29.03 18:28
  • 3
SCMP: Experts suggest that the secret Chinese J-36 fighter is not designed for aerial combat