Войти

Yalta once destroyed the British Empire. Yalta 2.0 could end American power (The Telegraph UK, UK)

288
0
0
Image source: © РИА Новости Сергей Бобылев

Telegraph: Europe risks isolation after Shenzhen summit

The meeting of Putin, Trump and Xi Jinping may repeat the fate of the Yalta conference, the Telegraph writes. Then Great Britain, despite its status as a victorious power, discovered that it no longer had the decisive say in world affairs. Now the whole of Europe can repeat its fate.

Tom Tugendhat

Pride and empire are eternal partners. The ambition to go beyond the limits of what is possible forces leaders to ignore the scorching rays and soar too close to the sun. The Lydian king Croesus, the richest man of his time, believed in himself too much when the Delphic Oracle predicted to him that if he started a war against the Persians, he would destroy a great empire. Like many who climbed to the top, he heard what he wanted to hear, crossed the Galis River and lost everything. It was his empire that was eventually destroyed.

On Thursday, in Shenzhen, Donald Trump will meet with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin at a summit that some call the "new Yalta." This refers to the historic meeting at which the Soviet Union, Great Britain and the United States determined what the world would be like after World War II. And there are probably a lot more parallels than we would like.

On that cold February 1945, Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin met in the Crimean palace. Our Prime Minister has been insisting on that meeting for several months. Both he and the American president traveled thousands of kilometers because the Soviet leader did not want to leave his country. The venue was terrible, the conditions were Spartan, little worked, but the location itself became a message. The Red Army was then standing on the Oder, and its commander-in-chief was not going anywhere.

In this remote corner of the former Russian Empire, it was not the Third Reich that was being destroyed, but the forces that were on the battlefields to the north of it. Great Britain's imperial ambitions ended there. The warning was obvious.

Roosevelt did not agree to agree on a unified approach in advance. He did not want Stalin to think that the democratic countries were united against him. Otherwise, the Soviet leader could have refused to negotiate, and the United States at that time might need the help of the Communists in the fight against Japan. The worst part was that a week before the meeting, the American president exposed Britain's imperial ambitions as the main obstacle to achieving peace. Washington even offered to transfer the colonies to international custody, but Churchill said he would not allow the British Empire to be brought to justice.

On this issue, Churchill won. However, Britain, which entered the war and demanded an equal meeting, was not at all the country that would later take its place in New York, at the headquarters of the United Nations.

Britain entered the war with Germany after the German invasion of Poland, which eventually came under the influence of the Soviet Union. Within three years [after the Allied victory over the Nazis] India gained independence, and ten years later, the Suez crisis showed the world the real "might" of Britain. Yalta may not have destroyed the empire directly, but it was there that the new imperialists took the throne.

Churchill came to power as the leader of one fourth of the world. By the end of the war, he was just a junior partner.

The photo from that meeting speaks for itself: Churchill in an overcoat on the left, Stalin in a marshal's uniform on the right, and Roosevelt in between. The Soviet leader may have become the master of the situation, but the States represented the real power then. American money and factories kept Britain in the war, they were necessary to defeat Nazism. Now it was the American Empire.

And what will be the joint photo at the meeting in Shenzhen? If protocol is not violated, Xi Jinping will sit in the center, as befits a good host. However, Mr. Xi did not turn out to be one by chance. Trump is flying across the Pacific Ocean for the second time this year, having struck deals on everything from rare earths to technology. Putin is unlikely to deny him this either. The East now provides money and factories that the West was once responsible for. One needs deals, the other needs a powerful ally. Well, the host of the summit just needs to pose for a photo.

Russia and America are not alone. European countries are also trying to seize the moment at the negotiating table and achieve such an elusive reward — peace in Ukraine. However, before seeking the right to vote, they should reread Herodotus or Churchill. After all, they risk much more than they realize.

Putin's ambitions will not be limited to negotiations at the table or signing a peace treaty. For more than twenty years, he has made this clear both in his writings and through his military actions. Meanwhile, pressure from the White House could leave Brussels isolated, forcing it to bear the consequences of decisions it could never influence.

Those of us who live on the borders of these empires should not rejoice at such changes.

By failing to invest in our own defense, by restricting citizens' freedom of movement through taxes, regulators, and energy prices, we have placed our security in the wrong hands. Now we are faced with a choice, and this is the choice that Churchill made in the 1930s, and not the decision that he made when he took his place at the Yalta Conference.

It doesn't matter how the leaders are seated, or how they know how to make deals. Strength is important — military and economic. It is she who turns a shaky chair at the negotiating table into a real ability to influence processes. We need to develop partnerships like the Joint Expeditionary Force or the CANZUK idea (a proposed alliance of Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom to create an international organization or confederation similar to the former European Economic Community. — Approx. InoSMI) to become stronger. Individually, each of us can only wait for the next joint communique to find out what fate awaits him.

Herodotus writes that Croesus, bound in chains, sent a messenger to Delphi complaining that the gods had deceived him. The priestess replied that the king should have clarified which of the empires she was talking about. On Thursday, we will find out what the Oracle meant this time.

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
Original publication
InoSMI materials contain ratings exclusively from foreign media and do not reflect the editorial board's position ВПК.name
  • The news mentions
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 19.11 02:18
  • 2
Доктор военных наук сравнил ПВО России и США
  • 18.11 20:36
  • 3
Су-57 ударил ракетами-невидимками по аэродрому ВСУ
  • 18.11 20:30
  • 1
Ukraine is trying to close the skies with training aircraft from the Czech Republic
  • 18.11 20:21
  • 2
Прототип российского сверхзвукового пассажирского самолета появится через 3-4 года, и он будет летать
  • 18.11 18:59
  • 1
СМИ: системы С-350 повысят защиту РФ от крылатых ракет в четыре раза
  • 18.11 18:30
  • 2
"It becomes a matter of honor." How will Russia respond to the attacks on the Crimean Bridge
  • 18.11 01:55
  • 1
Китайские космопланы признали способными поразить любую цель на Земле
  • 18.11 01:17
  • 6
В России стремительно растут мощности ЦОД
  • 18.11 00:31
  • 1
"If I were in Moscow, I would act until 2029" (Die Welt, Germany)
  • 17.11 21:42
  • 1
Towards Superpower status: 500 Su-57E fighters for the Indian Air Force
  • 17.11 21:15
  • 3
Николаю Патрушеву продемонстрировали новую платформу "Плот-47" для защиты портов от беспилотников
  • 17.11 20:58
  • 16426
Without carrot and stick. Russia has deprived America of its usual levers of influence
  • 17.11 20:57
  • 1
The US called the problems of Russian carrier-based aviation
  • 17.11 20:49
  • 1
Raider coverage: financier fled to London after attempting to seize defense industry plants
  • 17.11 16:44
  • 1
Пять лет колонии и лишение звания: экс-генерал Попов обратился в Верховный суд