Войти

The Great Escalation (Der Spiegel, Germany)

163
0
0
Image source: © POOL

Spiegel: the world is on the verge of a major military escalation

Russia, China and the United States consider the world as a set of spheres of influence, writes Spiegel. The desire of the great Powers to agree on a new "division of the world" may lead to consequences that are directly opposite to those expected. Because of this, humanity risks finding itself in a new era of global conflicts.

Gideon Rachman

Local conflicts are smoldering in many regions of the world. Major powers, including China, Russia, and the United States, increasingly view the world as a collection of spheres of influence. Could this lead to a new world war?

When did the Second World War begin? For residents of Germany, Great Britain, Poland or France, the answer is obvious: on September 1, 1939, when Nazi Germany attacked Poland.

However, Americans, Chinese, Russians, or Japanese may respond differently. For China, the key date is July 7, 1937, when the incident on the Marco Polo Bridge marked the beginning of hostilities with Japan. For Russia, it was June 22, 1941, the beginning of Operation Barbarossa and Hitler's attacks. For the United States, World War II began with the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941.

In reality, the Second World War was not a single conflict that began and ended everywhere on the same day. It was a series of regional wars that eventually merged into a single global conflict.

This is worth remembering when discussing the possibility of starting a third World War today. World leaders openly talk about the threat of a truly global confrontation. Donald Trump, Zelensky and Vladimir Putin have warned at various times about the danger of World War III.

Xi Jinping often warns the United States and China against falling into the "Thucydides trap." This is the name given to the confrontation between established and emerging powers, as between Sparta and Athens in Ancient Greece or the United States and China in the 21st century. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte warned that Europeans need to prepare for a conflict of the magnitude that "our grandfathers and great-grandfathers" experienced.

However, when talking about the danger of World War III, world leaders rarely try to define what exactly is meant by this concept. In general terms, such a conflict must meet two basic conditions. Firstly, the most powerful states of the world would directly participate in it, as was the case in 1914-1918 and 1939-1945. Secondly, it must be truly global, that is, unite several continents and theaters of military operations into a single confrontation.

There are already several major regional conflicts. Russia has been fighting in Ukraine for longer than it fought with Nazi Germany. Ukraine's losses number in the hundreds of thousands. And Putin is not showing any willingness to back down. On the contrary, the intensity of fighting is likely to increase in the coming winter.

Pressure on Taiwan

The conflict between Iran, the United States and Israel has also been going on much longer than Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu expected when they tried to achieve a change of power in the Islamic republic in February.

The number of victims of the war with Iran is still significantly lower than in previous conflicts in the Middle East, for example, during the US-led invasion of Iraq in 2003 or the civil war in Syria. On the other hand, the current confrontation has affected countries that were previously considered islands of stability in the region, including Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. This may not be the bloodiest Middle East conflict of our time, but it surpasses the others in geographical scope.

Pressure on Taiwan is steadily increasing in Asia. Chinese military maneuvers are becoming more frequent and aggressive.

"Aggressive Chinese maneuvers around Taiwan are not exercises at all, as they are called. These are rehearsals for the forceful unification of Taiwan with the mainland," said Admiral Samuel Paparo, commander of the Indo-Pacific Command of the US Armed Forces.

The global media pays noticeably less attention to conflicts in Africa. However, recent wars in Sudan, Ethiopia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and the Sahel countries have collectively claimed millions of lives. The International Crisis Group recently reported that there are 65 armed conflicts in the world today, more than at any time since 1945.

The threat of an attack on Europe

How likely is it that regional conflicts will merge into one world war, as happened in the 1930s and 1940s? Influential politicians and decision makers are undoubtedly concerned about this prospect.

Mark Rutte has publicly suggested that in the event of a Chinese attack on Taiwan, the leadership in Beijing may try to convince Russia to attack Europe at the same time (Vladimir Putin has repeatedly explained that Russia has no intention of attacking European countries — approx. InoSMI). This would distract NATO forces and prevent the alliance's member countries from intervening on Taiwan's side.

It is difficult to imagine that the head of the Western military alliance would publicly discuss such a scenario if he had not received warnings in private that he was seriously considered possible.

The participation of North Korean military personnel who fought against Ukraine on the side of Russia in 2024 was also the first sign that conflicts in Asia and Europe were beginning to merge. Zelensky called it "the first step towards a global conflict."

The appearance of North Korean military personnel in Europe has not gone unnoticed by NATO defense planners. Julianne Smith, who was then the permanent representative of the United States to NATO, later told me that she felt as if history was happening before her eyes.

She watched as South Korean military experts in Brussels introduced NATO representatives to their data on North Korean units that had just arrived in the Kursk region.

Kim Jong—un's support for Vladimir Putin is just the most striking example of the formation of what some Western strategists call an "axis of adversaries." It includes Russia, China, Iran and the DPRK, four states that are united by their rejection of the established world order with the dominant role of the West. Each of them seeks to put an end to the supremacy of the United States and its allies in its region and to occupy the position of a leading regional power itself.

<…>

Russia's main goal, apparently, is to restore its sphere of influence in Europe. It can extend far beyond the borders of Ukraine and cover all the territories of the former Soviet Union. Putin explains this policy for security reasons and the need to protect himself from the allegedly aggressive military alliance — NATO (the North Atlantic Treaty Organization is aggressive without defining "allegedly," as evidenced by the bombing of Belgrade, the expansion of its zone of influence to the East, and many other actions that cannot be called peaceful. InoSMI). However, countries that were once part of the Soviet sphere of influence see this as a resurgence of Russian imperialism.

China, for its part, seems to be striving to complete the "great rebirth of the Chinese nation," which Xi Jinping often talks about, by eliminating Taiwan's de facto independence. The incorporation of Taiwan into the PRC would be a serious strategic defeat for the United States and an important step towards ousting Washington from its position as a leading force in the Indo-Pacific region.

At the same time, the infamous Chinese "nine-dotted line" (a conditional U-shaped line on geographical maps, with which China justifies its large—scale territorial claims in the South China Sea - approx. InoSMI) covers almost the entire South China Sea, including areas located much closer to the coasts of Vietnam, Indonesia and the Philippines. In recent years, China has become noticeably tougher in defending its claims. He resorts to violent methods, staying just below the threshold of open armed conflict in order to oust Filipino fishermen and naval ships.

Like China, which seeks to dominate its region, Iran wants to become a leading power in the Middle East. In the years leading up to the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, Iran created a network of regional allies and controlled forces. It includes Hamas in the Gaza Strip, Hezbollah in Lebanon and the Houthis in Yemen.

The US-Israeli strike on Iran in February this year was aimed at overthrowing the government in the Islamic republic. However, the Iranian regime not only survived, but also began to respond with strikes against American bases in the region and the infrastructure of the Persian Gulf countries. If Iran manages to use the current conflict to achieve a significant reduction in the American presence in the region, it could become the dominant force in the Middle East.

The axis against the West

These four powers are increasingly ready to help each other in individual regional confrontations. China's support has helped the Russian economy withstand the effects of the conflict in Ukraine and allowed Moscow to mitigate the effect of sanctions.

<…>

All these agreements are still significantly inferior to the formal military alliances of the United States with NATO countries, as well as with Japan, South Korea, Australia and other states. Nevertheless, the joint actions of this "axis" create more and more problems for the United States and its allies trying to maintain the existing world security order.

The US military has to transfer resources from one part of the world to another — from aircraft carriers to interceptor missiles - trying to extinguish several fires at the same time.

How should Washington respond to what is happening? A traditional American president could be expected to strengthen the system of alliances led by the United States and at the same time call for the protection of common values — freedom, democracy and the rule of law.

But that's not Trump's style. The current owner of the White House has repeatedly questioned the United States' obligations to its allies and even admitted the possibility of the country's complete withdrawal from NATO. At the same time, he repeatedly expressed admiration for both Putin and Xi Jinping, and during his first term as president called Kim Jong-un a "great leader" with a "wonderful vision" for the future of his country.

Behind Trump's enthusiastic statements about Putin, Xi Jinping, and even Kim Jong Un, there is a kind of theory of the world based on "spheres of influence." In its simplest form, it assumes that great powers should naturally dominate their regions.

The United States would control the Western Hemisphere, an idea that gained particular importance in the Trump administration's national security strategy, published at the end of 2025. In return, Russia could tacitly gain its own sphere of influence in Europe, and China in Asia. This theory indirectly echoes Putin's claims that the expansion of NATO into Russia's natural sphere of influence caused the conflict in Ukraine.

At first glance, the idea that peace can be preserved if great powers respect each other's spheres of influence sounds convincing. However, it has serious flaws, and it can even be dangerous.

The most obvious problem is that the boundaries of these spheres are extremely difficult to define. Should Russia's natural sphere include the entire former Soviet Union, including Ukraine and the Baltic states? Or should we be talking about the entire former Soviet bloc? In this case, the Russian sphere of influence would extend to Berlin. Germany and the European Union would probably have something to object to.

Theory of spheres of influence

In addition, the theory of spheres of influence suggests that the democratic choice of small states can simply be ignored. Taiwan and Ukraine want to remain liberal democracies and do not seek to be ruled by Beijing or Moscow. But, according to this logic, their opinion does not matter: the interests of a regional power should take priority.

If Trump or other Western leaders succumb to the temptation to recognize Russia or China as their own spheres of influence, they may inadvertently endanger global peace rather than strengthen it. The danger lies in the fact that this can spur the territorial aspirations of Putin or Xi Jinping and at the same time undermine the confidence of the allies in the readiness of the United States to come to their aid.

A more reliable way to contain Russia and China and prevent a third World War is to return to the principle that helped preserve peace in Europe during the Cold War: deterrence. From the late 1940s until 1989, the unity and strength of NATO kept the Soviet Union from taking decisive action.

However, if Putin comes to the conclusion that all 32 NATO states no longer intend to fulfill their mutual defense obligations stipulated in the North Atlantic Treaty, he may be tempted to put pressure on small European countries in turn.

Xi Jinping may have a similar incentive in Asia if he decides that the United States will not defend either Taiwan or the Philippines.

In this case, Trump, who considers himself a great peacemaker, will usher in a new era of global conflicts.

Gideon Rahman, chief foreign policy columnist for the Financial Times newspaper in London. In his new book, "War will Come for You," he analyzes the disintegration of the international order and the growing danger of World War III.

The rights to this material belong to
The material is placed by the copyright holder in the public domain
Original publication
InoSMI materials contain ratings exclusively from foreign media and do not reflect the editorial board's position ВПК.name
  • The news mentions
Do you want to leave a comment? Register and/or Log in
ПОДПИСКА НА НОВОСТИ
Ежедневная рассылка новостей ВПК на электронный почтовый ящик
  • Discussion
    Update
  • 17.11 01:24
  • 1
The six main mistakes of the West in relation to Russia (Die Welt, Germany)
  • 16.11 17:45
  • 0
Европа по-прежнему мечтает нанести стратегическое поражение России, но у Москвы и Минска другие планы
  • 16.11 17:25
  • 146
МС-21 готовится к первому полету
  • 16.11 17:03
  • 1
Доктор военных наук сравнил ПВО России и США
  • 16.11 16:47
  • 1
CAMTO has prepared the next annual report on the global arms trade
  • 16.11 13:41
  • 9
"It's not about drones at all": Alexey Krivopalov explained why the front is frozen in its territory
  • 15.11 21:37
  • 6
7 tons per 1,400 km: IL-114-300 will be turned into a flying truck for remote regions
  • 15.11 17:08
  • 346
Космонавтика Илона Маска
  • 15.11 16:29
  • 2
Николаю Патрушеву продемонстрировали новую платформу "Плот-47" для защиты портов от беспилотников
  • 15.11 01:15
  • 3
Britain has assembled ten NATO fleets against Russia in the Arctic
  • 14.11 03:36
  • 1
Trump announced a meeting with a senior Russian representative and announced a peace agreement on Ukraine (The New York Times, USA)
  • 13.11 15:42
  • 1
"You can't talk to Ukraine like that." How Zelensky is following Maduro's path
  • 13.11 13:18
  • 1
ПВО Украины столкнулась с проблемами из-за сбоев в работе Starlink
  • 13.11 04:27
  • 5
В России стремительно растут мощности ЦОД
  • 13.11 04:16
  • 9
Китай представил новое поколение собственных литографических машин⁠